Welcome to Coney Island Lunch, a charming little diner located at 3015 Buffalo Rd, Erie, PA. This gem of the city invites you to experience a delightful intersection of nostalgia and affordability, where food lovers gather for hearty meals that don't break the bank. Known for serving the best Greek burgers in Erie, Coney Island Lunch makes a mark not just with its food but also with its warm, welcoming service. As one customer, Preston Thompson, aptly put it, the staff greets patrons by name, making every visit feel special.

The diner is celebrated for its affordability. With dishes like a hearty Greek burger and fries available for just $6, guests can indulge without guilt. James Condon’s review highlights the charm of the diner atmosphere, and it's clear that this spot provides more than just meals; it offers memories wrapped in simplicity. The rich aroma from the kitchen might linger, but that’s all part of the experience of dining in a cozy, small-town eatery.

The ambiance at Coney Island Lunch is reminiscent of a 1970s diner, drawing you into a world where food serves as an affordable pleasure. Kaitlin Smith commends the sizable milkshakes, affirming that not only is the food good, but it also comes at a price that feels nostalgic for many returning customers. Be mindful though; cash is king here, adding an air of authenticity to your dining experience.

For families or quick bites on the run, simple yet satisfying eats are what you’ll find. Reviews from diners like Jon K. and Tara Mlacker reinforce this notion, emphasizing the friendly service and the quick, tasty meals ideal for a little date or a quick work break. It’s a haven for simple, fast food that keeps patrons coming back for more.

However, not all experiences are without hiccups; some patrons, like Dinger, have voiced preferences regarding how their food is served, demonstrating the diner’s willingness to evolve based on customer feedback. But one thing remains constant: the love for Greek dogs, delicious burgers, and crispy fries has stayed eternal. 

In essence, Coney Island Lunch is not just a place to eat; it embodies a slice of Erie’s culture, where budget-friendly meals mingle with a heartwarming atmosphere. Whether you're craving that mouthwatering Greek burger or a classic milkshake, stepping into Coney Island Lunch feels like stepping back in time, filled with flavors and experiences waiting to be cherished. Your next meal awaits in this beloved diner, and the only thing left is for you to dive in!